Monday, May 21, 2012

2012 Electoral College Prediction

As of today, I see the President starting with 195 electoral votes in the bank and Mitt Romney with 170.  From there, here's the breakdown:

Likely Obama (22)
Maine's 2nd District (1)
Michigan (16)
New Mexico (5)

Likely Romney (21)
Arizona (11)
Missouri (10)

That gets us to Obama 217-191.  Then:

Lean Obama (30)
Pennsylvania (20)
Wisconsin (10)

Lean Romney (15)
North Carolina (15)

Obama 247-206.  That leaves 7 toss-up states, which I rank in order of likelihood to go to Romney:

1.  Florida (29)
2.  Ohio (18)
3.  Virginia (13)
4.  Iowa (6)
5.  Colorado (9)
6.  New Hampshire (4)
7.  Nevada (6)

As of today, I'd only give Florida to Romney.  That leaves us with Obama winning 303-235.  Romney would need to also win Ohio, Virginia, and Iowa to pull into the lead, 272-266.  There is a path for Romney, but there aren't many ways for him to get to 270.

2012 Senate Rankings and Predictions

2012 Senate Prediction

As of today, this is my ranking of the seats most likely to flip.

1.  Maine (R -- Open/Snowe).  Angus King.  We'll be hearing that name a lot between November and January.  After that?  We'll see.

2.  Nebraska (D -- Open/Nelson).  If the only dirt on Deb Fischer is that she was one of a handful of ranchers to get large government checks for setting aside grazing land, she will win.  Unless she proves to be not remotely ready for prime-time, she will sail through.

3.  North Dakota (D -- Open/Conrad).  This is going to be close.  I don't buy last week's Fargo Forum poll showing an 8-point Berg lead, but in the long run, he has the advantage.

4.  Massachusetts (R -- Brown).  Elizabeth Warren has had a bad couple of weeks, but I still think Scott Brown is the most endangered incumbent.

5. Missouri (D -- McCaskill). It's a remarkably weak Republican field, but the senator has clear vulnerabilities.

6. Montana (D -- Tester). Tester barely beat a flawed incumbent in a great Democratic year 6 years ago. It will be another nail-biter.

7.  Wisconsin (D -- Open/Kohl).  I don't expect the Republicans to nominate Tommy Thompson, but if they did, this would move even higher.

8.  Nevada (R -- Heller).  Lots of people wonder how Shelley Berkeley will sell in northern Nevada.  The better question is how will Heller do in Clark County. 

9.  Virginia (D -- Open/Webb).  I expect Kaine to ride African-American turnout to a narrow victory.

10. New Mexico (D -- Open/Bingaman). It's not clear how targeted New Mexico will be by the presidential campaigns. The Democrats could use ramped-up Hispanic turnout here.

11.  Indiana (R -- Open/Lugar).  Mourdock agrees with repealing the 17th Amendment?  The Democrats assigned a tracker to him throughout the primary campaign -- expect some interesting ads this fall.

12.  Ohio (D -- Brown).  I've been surprised by Mandel's staying power despite some bad headlines about how he's run the State Treasurer's office.

13.  Arizona (R -- Open/Kyl).  The big question here is whether Jeff Flake needs to start sweating his primary.

14.  Michigan (D - Stabenow).  A more moderate Republican candidate could have made this a real race.

15.  Florida (D - Nelson).  One would have thought that Rep. Connie Mack was being groomed for a Senate run someday.  He's had a very rough start.  George Lemieux might get the nomination yet.

16.  Hawaii (D -- Open/Akaka).  Not going to be competitive.

As of today, I predict the top 6 seats will flip.  That would leave the Senate with a 49-49 Senate with Sanders joining the Democrats and ... Angus King.